Yeah its just disappointing when they don't do advanced topics that are in the rules... I'm used to NYS having rules and then some random stuff on top of it, but I've been disappointed this year with how simple the concepts on the tests were, I'd like to see a more challenging test in the future.cyanophycean314 wrote:At Indiana, our State test made each team split into two parts, a lab portion consisting of five stations and a very long test. Because there were stations and the other person was in another room sometimes, it made consulting about things kinda weird.
I manned the test portion and it didn't cover too many advanced topics. It was definitely all within phys B level. They tried to squeeze you with the time limit, but I still finished with time to spare.
In the end, my partner messed up one of the labs, but that's ok because we got 1st! It was a very happy conclusion to my season.
Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
- Unbihexium
- Member
- Posts: 31
- Joined: May 21st, 2012, 4:01 pm
- Division: C
- State: NY
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
2012 Regionals: 5th Towers
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
- tangentline
- Member
- Posts: 30
- Joined: September 29th, 2012, 6:17 pm
- Division: Grad
- State: CA
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
Cough. What laws are you using when you are using node voltage. Well, with some of the explanations I've been hearing on these forums as well, Kirchhoff would be the quick and easy answer that makes things make more sense.Unbihexium wrote: Also, who needs Kirchhoff's laws when you have node voltage analysis?
- Unbihexium
- Member
- Posts: 31
- Joined: May 21st, 2012, 4:01 pm
- Division: C
- State: NY
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
I know perfectly well that Nodal analysis is an application of Kirchhoff's laws, its simple a much more effective version... And sure, kirchhoff's are easy for some situation, but nodal is practically guaranteed to give you fewer equations...tangentline wrote:Cough. What laws are you using when you are using node voltage. Well, with some of the explanations I've been hearing on these forums as well, Kirchhoff would be the quick and easy answer that makes things make more sense.Unbihexium wrote: Also, who needs Kirchhoff's laws when you have node voltage analysis?
2012 Regionals: 5th Towers
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
-
- Member
- Posts: 18
- Joined: January 5th, 2013, 4:00 pm
- Division: C
- State: WA
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
I hate nodal analysis I think mesh or the superposition theorem are a lot simpler haha
Camas/Regionals/State
Astronomy (4/2/2)
Fermi (1/2/6)
Tech Problem Solving (1/3/4)
Circuits (2/4/1)
Experimental (7/1/2)
MagLev(-/2/8)
Astronomy (4/2/2)
Fermi (1/2/6)
Tech Problem Solving (1/3/4)
Circuits (2/4/1)
Experimental (7/1/2)
MagLev(-/2/8)
- Unbihexium
- Member
- Posts: 31
- Joined: May 21st, 2012, 4:01 pm
- Division: C
- State: NY
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
Really? mesh is just Kirchhoff's loop rule with a little simplification, and superposition is slower than node not to mention it only works for linear circuits... I'm confused of the advantages here.. I do like simplifying to thevenins/nortons though if i'm analyzing something that can be helped that way...fourLoko wrote:I hate nodal analysis I think mesh or the superposition theorem are a lot simpler haha
2012 Regionals: 5th Towers
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
-
- Member
- Posts: 18
- Joined: January 5th, 2013, 4:00 pm
- Division: C
- State: WA
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
Superposition can totally work for non-linear circuits with multiple voltage sources...Unbihexium wrote:Really? mesh is just Kirchhoff's loop rule with a little simplification, and superposition is slower than node not to mention it only works for linear circuits... I'm confused of the advantages here.. I do like simplifying to thevenins/nortons though if i'm analyzing something that can be helped that way...fourLoko wrote:I hate nodal analysis I think mesh or the superposition theorem are a lot simpler haha
Camas/Regionals/State
Astronomy (4/2/2)
Fermi (1/2/6)
Tech Problem Solving (1/3/4)
Circuits (2/4/1)
Experimental (7/1/2)
MagLev(-/2/8)
Astronomy (4/2/2)
Fermi (1/2/6)
Tech Problem Solving (1/3/4)
Circuits (2/4/1)
Experimental (7/1/2)
MagLev(-/2/8)
- Unbihexium
- Member
- Posts: 31
- Joined: May 21st, 2012, 4:01 pm
- Division: C
- State: NY
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
Linear circuits have nothing to do with number of voltage sources a linear circuit means all elements have linear VI curves as opposed to things like diodes...google is your friend you missunderstand the deffinitionfourLoko wrote:Superposition can totally work for non-linear circuits with multiple voltage sources...Unbihexium wrote:Really? mesh is just Kirchhoff's loop rule with a little simplification, and superposition is slower than node not to mention it only works for linear circuits... I'm confused of the advantages here.. I do like simplifying to thevenins/nortons though if i'm analyzing something that can be helped that way...fourLoko wrote:I hate nodal analysis I think mesh or the superposition theorem are a lot simpler haha
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_circuit#section_1
2012 Regionals: 5th Towers
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
- tangentline
- Member
- Posts: 30
- Joined: September 29th, 2012, 6:17 pm
- Division: Grad
- State: CA
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
I think labeling our techniques is more confusing than just stating a problem and the steps taken to solve it.
Superposition, Node/Mesh Analysis, Thevenin/Norton, Kirchhoff, etc are all techniques that I just use intermixed to solve a problem the fastest way I see possible. If I see a viable shortcut to the "usual" method, I'll take it. There have been problems for example that "superposition" (I'm labeling) provides a quick and easy fix to multiple batteries---it depends on the question that is asked, especially if it isn't asking to find literally everything you can out of a circuit, there often is a faster way to find elements such as the current in one spot.
Besides, I have a calculator that solves systems of however many equations, so no big worry.
Superposition, Node/Mesh Analysis, Thevenin/Norton, Kirchhoff, etc are all techniques that I just use intermixed to solve a problem the fastest way I see possible. If I see a viable shortcut to the "usual" method, I'll take it. There have been problems for example that "superposition" (I'm labeling) provides a quick and easy fix to multiple batteries---it depends on the question that is asked, especially if it isn't asking to find literally everything you can out of a circuit, there often is a faster way to find elements such as the current in one spot.
Besides, I have a calculator that solves systems of however many equations, so no big worry.
- Unbihexium
- Member
- Posts: 31
- Joined: May 21st, 2012, 4:01 pm
- Division: C
- State: NY
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
Ditto on that, same story i choose whats best at the moment and a calculator like that helps me alot too.. also i put a transient network analysis program on my calc in case some weird circuit came uptangentline wrote:I think labeling our techniques is more confusing than just stating a problem and the steps taken to solve it.
Superposition, Node/Mesh Analysis, Thevenin/Norton, Kirchhoff, etc are all techniques that I just use intermixed to solve a problem the fastest way I see possible. If I see a viable shortcut to the "usual" method, I'll take it. There have been problems for example that "superposition" (I'm labeling) provides a quick and easy fix to multiple batteries---it depends on the question that is asked, especially if it isn't asking to find literally everything you can out of a circuit, there often is a faster way to find elements such as the current in one spot.
Besides, I have a calculator that solves systems of however many equations, so no big worry.
2012 Regionals: 5th Towers
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Athens Twin Tiers Invites: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
2013 Regionals: 1st Boomilever, 1st Fermi, 1st Circuit Lab
2013 New York States: 3rd Fermi, 3rd Circuit Lab
-
- Admin Emeritus
- Posts: 1115
- Joined: May 10th, 2011, 8:25 pm
- Division: Grad
- State: TX
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 1 time
Re: Shock Value B/Circuit Lab C
Wow... what kinds of tests have you all been getting? I've seen one test(out of 4 this year) that had norton and thevenin equivalents, and I haven't seen anything complicated from a circuit analysis standpoint. All I've seen is a battery and a resistor network... Maybe a charge curve equation or two, and one test had a diode thrown in just to trick people. sigh....
'If you're the smartest person in the room, you're in the wrong room' - Unknown
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests