Page 11 of 16

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 18th, 2014, 7:51 am
by abby1kanobe
Lets add in these results for comparison purposes:

West Liberty Salem invitational

1.Solon 89, 2. Bearden 168, 3.Magsig 170, 4. Grandview Heights 205, 5. Tower Heights 212, 6. Watts 214

Booth Invitational

1.Booth 99, 2 Piedmont 122, 3. Bearden 141, 4.Dodgen 198, 5. Fulton Science Academy 257, 6.Dodgen B 296, 7.Auburn A 305

Chatahoochee Inviational

1.Dodgen MS 86, 2.Bearden MS 93, 3.Fulton Science Academy 100, 4.Auburn 128

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 18th, 2014, 10:21 am
by rfscoach
Lets add in these results for comparison purposes:

West Liberty Salem invitational

1.Solon 89, 2. Bearden 168, 3.Magsig 170, 4. Grandview Heights 205, 5. Tower Heights 212, 6. Watts 214

Booth Invitational

1.Booth 99, 2 Piedmont 122, 3. Bearden 141, 4.Dodgen 198, 5. Fulton Science Academy 257, 6.Dodgen B 296, 7.Auburn A 305

Chatahoochee Inviational

1.Dodgen MS 86, 2.Bearden MS 93, 3.Fulton Science Academy 100, 4.Auburn 128

I really wouldn't count any results from the Chattahoochee Invite. November Invites are too early in the season to judge anything and are all about seeing how the new kids do...

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 18th, 2014, 2:38 pm
by mrburrito
Oh, look at this. The thread has returned, I should check this site more often.

1. Daniel Wright
2. Solon
3. Winston Churchill
4. Science and Arts
5. Mentor Memorial
6. Meads Mill
7. Beckondorff
8. Paul J. Gelinas
9. Shady Side
10. Booth

This is the correct answer :D

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 18th, 2014, 3:07 pm
by havenbreadfish
Oh, look at this. The thread has returned, I should check this site more often.

1. Daniel Wright
2. Solon
3. Winston Churchill
4. Marie Murphy
5. Mentor Memorial
6. Meads Mill
7. Beckondorff
8. Paul J. Gelinas
9. Shady Side
10. Booth

This is the correct answer :D
The fact that Marie Murphy won't be at nationals automatically makes this incorrect. :P Science and Arts Academy beat them in a tie at states. Other than that, yeah, these seem to be decent rankings. I'd imagine Beckendorff would be a bit higher, but it gets really tough at this point.

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 18th, 2014, 4:03 pm
by noodleluvr
I still think that Beckendorff should be placed higher.

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 18th, 2014, 6:57 pm
by Adi1008
It would be tough for me to give each team their own rankings. Last year, the results were extremely close between some of the schools (e.g., Daniel Wright and Solon and a tie between Meads Mill and Winston Churchill), so I'm going to place them in tiers instead. Within each tier, I expect those teams to fight it out against each other. All of my listings are in no particular order within each tier.

1st and 2nd: Solon and Daniel Wright
3rd through 5th: Meads Mill, Winston Churchill, Beckendorff
6th through 10th: Mentor Memorial , Paul J. Gelinas, SSA, JC Booth, Muscatel
I still think that Beckendorff should be placed higher.
I personally believe Beckendorff's success will lie in how well its building events do. Last year, their study events were extremely solid (with the exception of R4TS), but they bombed Helicopters (51st), Rotor (43rd), and (depending on your definition of bombed) Mousetrap (31st). Had they been around 20th or 30th, I believe they could have easily been a top 5 team. While the same could be said for other teams (Mentor Memorial got 50th in Sounds of Music and Meads Mill got 56th [!] in Mousetrap), I personally feel as if it applies to Beckendorff more. However, we can't really say for sure until state. The regionals they went to was plagued with some questionable scoring and placements for all teams, and they never really had a stacked team during the invitationals.

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 18th, 2014, 7:06 pm
by ckssv07
It would be tough for me to give each team their own rankings. Last year, the results were extremely close between some of the schools (e.g., Daniel Wright and Solon and a tie between Meads Mill and Winston Churchill), so I'm going to place them in tiers instead. Within each tier, I expect those teams to fight it out against each other. All of my listings are in no particular order within each tier.

1st and 2nd: Solon and Daniel Wright
3rd through 5th: Meads Mill, Winston Churchill, Beckendorff
6th through 10th: Mentor Memorial , Paul J. Gelinas, SSA, JC Booth, Muscatel
I still think that Beckendorff should be placed higher.
I personally believe Beckendorff's success will lie in how well its building events do. Last year, their study events were extremely solid (with the exception of R4TS), but they bombed Helicopters (51st), Rotor (43rd), and (depending on your definition of bombed) Mousetrap (31st). Had they been around 20th or 30th, I believe they could have easily been a top 5 team. While the same could be said for other teams (Mentor Memorial got 50th in Sounds of Music and Meads Mill got 56th [!] in Mousetrap), I personally feel as if it applies to Beckendorff more. However, we can't really say for sure until state. The regionals they went to was plagued with some questionable scoring and placements for all teams, and they never really had a stacked team during the invitationals.
I think that's pretty accurate but I would put Booth in place of memorial.

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 18th, 2014, 10:19 pm
by mrburrito
Oh, look at this. The thread has returned, I should check this site more often.

1. Daniel Wright
2. Solon
3. Winston Churchill
4. Marie Murphy
5. Mentor Memorial
6. Meads Mill
7. Beckondorff
8. Paul J. Gelinas
9. Shady Side
10. Booth

This is the correct answer :D
The fact that Marie Murphy won't be at nationals automatically makes this incorrect. :P Science and Arts Academy beat them in a tie at states. Other than that, yeah, these seem to be decent rankings. I'd imagine Beckendorff would be a bit higher, but it gets really tough at this point.
Lol, haven't been paying attention, I just assumed they would win. I fixed it now.

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 19th, 2014, 7:55 am
by Unome
Oh, look at this. The thread has returned, I should check this site more often.

1. Daniel Wright
2. Solon
3. Winston Churchill
4. Marie Murphy
5. Mentor Memorial
6. Meads Mill
7. Beckondorff
8. Paul J. Gelinas
9. Shady Side
10. Booth

This is the correct answer :D
The fact that Marie Murphy won't be at nationals automatically makes this incorrect. :P Science and Arts Academy beat them in a tie at states. Other than that, yeah, these seem to be decent rankings. I'd imagine Beckendorff would be a bit higher, but it gets really tough at this point.
Lol, haven't been paying attention, I just assumed they would win. I fixed it now.
I'm still completely confident that Dodgen will make top ten.

Re: Unofficial Rankings B

Posted: April 19th, 2014, 1:26 pm
by qwertyuiop1234567890
Oh, look at this. The thread has returned, I should check this site more often.

1. Daniel Wright
2. Solon
3. Winston Churchill
4. Science and Arts
5. Mentor Memorial
6. Meads Mill
7. Beckondorff
8. Paul J. Gelinas
9. Shady Side
10. Booth

This is the correct answer :D
I think Meads Mill will place higher. Didn't they get second at Solon (behind Solon)?