Water Task

andrew lorino
Member
Member
Posts: 66
Joined: November 4th, 2015, 4:00 pm
Division: C
State: NY
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Water Task

Post by andrew lorino »

Unome wrote:
Kyanite wrote:So the FAQS said you cant use salt water for the water task, would pouring the water into a container that has dry salt be against these rules? What do you all think?
That seems to be legal to me. So long as the water being poured is not saltwater, it should be fine. However, you're probably better off doing something more reliable, like this:
davecutting wrote:So could we add water to a container that weighs it and presses a limit switch?
Couldn't the phrase "add water to a closed container so that it completes a circuit..." be seen as only allowing the water itself to close the circuit by using its own conductivity?
ScottMaurer19
Member
Member
Posts: 592
Joined: January 5th, 2017, 9:39 am
Division: Grad
State: OH
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Water Task

Post by ScottMaurer19 »

andrew lorino wrote:
Unome wrote:
Kyanite wrote:So the FAQS said you cant use salt water for the water task, would pouring the water into a container that has dry salt be against these rules? What do you all think?
That seems to be legal to me. So long as the water being poured is not saltwater, it should be fine. However, you're probably better off doing something more reliable, like this:
davecutting wrote:So could we add water to a container that weighs it and presses a limit switch?
Couldn't the phrase "add water to a closed container so that it completes a circuit..." be seen as only allowing the water itself to close the circuit by using its own conductivity?
Yes BUT the way it is currently written (per coaches clinic) is that a circuit can be completed anyway. Not just through water's conductivity
Solon '19 Captain, CWRU '23
2017 (r/s/n):
Hydro: 3/5/18
Robot Arm: na/1/1
Rocks: 1/1/1

2018 (r/s/n):
Heli: 2/1/7 
Herp: 1/4/4
Mission: 1/1/6
Rocks: 1/1/1
Eco: 6/3/9

2019 (r/s/n):
Fossils: 1/1/1
GLM: 1/1/1
Herp: 1/1/5
Mission: 1/1/3
WS: 4/1/10

Top 3 Medals: 144
Golds: 80
SluffAndRuff
Member
Member
Posts: 69
Joined: November 27th, 2015, 8:26 am
Division: B
State: VA
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Water Task

Post by SluffAndRuff »

A little off topic but if a limit switch can be used, does a Lego NXT Touch Sensor fit the bill as well? I'm being a bit lazy for Invites and going the Lego route - does anyone know if a Touch Sensor works the same way (closes a circuit upon actuation)?
()_]_[___]_[_/_]..... .. .. ... . . .
()'''''''''''''''''''''
Dark Sabre
Admin Emeritus
Admin Emeritus
Posts: 705
Joined: January 4th, 2004, 5:53 pm
Division: Grad
State: KY
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Water Task

Post by Dark Sabre »

My personal take on the task description:
If I press a switch with my finger, my finger is not completing the circuit because my finger is not a conductor in the circuit. I am pressing a switch. The switch is completing the circuit.
If I touch between two high voltage lines, my finger is completing a circuit (to my detriment).

I think the spirit of the problem is clear to use water to "complete"/bridge an incomplete circuit.

Another way to phrase my perspective on the limit switch scenario: Is the water completing a circuit or tipping a (tiny) lever?

That said, the grape vine says that a weight approach is acceptable and I'm of course perfectly happy to follow FAQ answers whenever they appear.

If a limit switch to detect the weight of the water is acceptable, then I don't see any reason I wouldn't accept a wide variety of scenarios incorporating mechanical force. If the NXT touch sensor operates on a make/break basis, I'd lump it in with limit switches. If it uses something like a slide potentiometer to change resistance then it is not completing a circuit (only adjusting the resistance of it). I had RCX instead of NXT, so I don't know the answer off-hand. If the software only allows for on/off feedback from the sensor, I suspect it is probably a make/break device.

Keep in mind that the grape vine also indicates that an NXT microprocessor is an adjustable physical object and so can only be used on one assigned action (no FAQ on the topic as of yet). Which would make it a pretty expensive alternative to a limit switch :P
nicholasmaurer
Coach
Coach
Posts: 422
Joined: May 19th, 2017, 10:55 am
Division: Grad
State: OH
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 22 times

Re: Water Task

Post by nicholasmaurer »

The FAQ posted today seems to contradict (and therefore overrule) the guidance given at the coach's clinic. Since "it" in 4.b.iv is being defined as "the water" per the FAQ, the water itself must complete the circuit. This rules out using the weight of the container to trigger a switch.
Assistant Coach and Alumnus ('14) - Solon High School Science Olympiad
Tournament Director - Northeast Ohio Regional Tournament
Tournament Director - Solon High School Science Olympiad Invitational

Opinions expressed on this site are not official; the only place for official rules changes and FAQs is soinc.org.
ScottMaurer19
Member
Member
Posts: 592
Joined: January 5th, 2017, 9:39 am
Division: Grad
State: OH
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Water Task

Post by ScottMaurer19 »

nicholasmaurer wrote:The FAQ posted today seems to contradict (and therefore overrule) the guidance given at the coach's clinic. Since "it" in 4.b.iv is being defined as "the water" per the FAQ, the water itself must complete the circuit. This rules out using the weight of the container to trigger a switch.
One could argue that the water is the "it" closing the circuit. Just with weight.
Solon '19 Captain, CWRU '23
2017 (r/s/n):
Hydro: 3/5/18
Robot Arm: na/1/1
Rocks: 1/1/1

2018 (r/s/n):
Heli: 2/1/7 
Herp: 1/4/4
Mission: 1/1/6
Rocks: 1/1/1
Eco: 6/3/9

2019 (r/s/n):
Fossils: 1/1/1
GLM: 1/1/1
Herp: 1/1/5
Mission: 1/1/3
WS: 4/1/10

Top 3 Medals: 144
Golds: 80
User avatar
Snarknado
Member
Member
Posts: 46
Joined: March 5th, 2017, 8:24 pm
Division: C
State: WA
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Water Task

Post by Snarknado »

SluffAndRuff wrote:A little off topic but if a limit switch can be used, does a Lego NXT Touch Sensor fit the bill as well? I'm being a bit lazy for Invites and going the Lego route - does anyone know if a Touch Sensor works the same way (closes a circuit upon actuation)?
Tell us how the Lego route pans out for you! I originally wanted to do that but my partner and I came to the consensus that it wasn't worth the time investment as we'd have to rebuild later when switching to more capable and compact arduinos.

As far as your actual question (assuming the entire idea of using weight is still valid), it might work, but to be safe I wouldn't. Just use a non-NXT circuit to activate the next action and save the NXTs for when you really need them.
Raisbeck Aviation High School Wiki
Snarknado's Userpage
"All we can do now is pray to Hot Glue Cthulu"
Ash123
Member
Member
Posts: 64
Joined: January 5th, 2018, 9:17 pm
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Allowed to use battery?

Post by Ash123 »

Hey guys
For the water task, are we allowed to include a 9v battery in our design? Other than losing the bonus, is it necessary? I’m doing a saltwater cell, but I am confused as to whether or not we are only allowed to use flow batteries.
radioactivated
Member
Member
Posts: 9
Joined: April 11th, 2016, 5:34 pm
Division: Grad
State: OH
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Allowed to use battery?

Post by radioactivated »

Ash123 wrote:Hey guys
For the water task, are we allowed to include a 9v battery in our design? Other than losing the bonus, is it necessary? I’m doing a saltwater cell, but I am confused as to whether or not we are only allowed to use flow batteries.
On a similar note, would adding water to form a voltaic pile count as an added battery and therefore remove the battery bonus?
ScottMaurer19
Member
Member
Posts: 592
Joined: January 5th, 2017, 9:39 am
Division: Grad
State: OH
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Allowed to use battery?

Post by ScottMaurer19 »

radioactivated wrote:
Ash123 wrote:Hey guys
For the water task, are we allowed to include a 9v battery in our design? Other than losing the bonus, is it necessary? I’m doing a saltwater cell, but I am confused as to whether or not we are only allowed to use flow batteries.
On a similar note, would adding water to form a voltaic pile count as an added battery and therefore remove the battery bonus?
As long as it is not supplying power then I wouldn't be concerned. Now if you added water in order to form a cell and power a circuit and not simply complete a circuit then that would be an added battery IMO.
Solon '19 Captain, CWRU '23
2017 (r/s/n):
Hydro: 3/5/18
Robot Arm: na/1/1
Rocks: 1/1/1

2018 (r/s/n):
Heli: 2/1/7 
Herp: 1/4/4
Mission: 1/1/6
Rocks: 1/1/1
Eco: 6/3/9

2019 (r/s/n):
Fossils: 1/1/1
GLM: 1/1/1
Herp: 1/1/5
Mission: 1/1/3
WS: 4/1/10

Top 3 Medals: 144
Golds: 80
Locked

Return to “Mission Possible C”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests