Towers B/C

Locked
User avatar
MadCow2357
Exalted Member
Exalted Member
Posts: 774
Joined: November 19th, 2017, 9:09 am
Division: C
State: RI
Has thanked: 211 times
Been thanked: 56 times
Contact:

Re: Towers B/C

Post by MadCow2357 »

stevepilot wrote:Does anyone know if 1/32 x 1/32 wood would be strong enough for the chimney X's (provided a fairly tight interval of 8-10 X)? Also, is it necessary to have a ladder at the top of the chimney or is it only needed at the top and bottom of the base?
Seems most elite teams are going with 1/16"*1/32". I think that 1/32"*1/32" would be overkill. I would say the ladder at the top is pretty essential. Mine is a 1/8" stick.
MadCow2357's Userpage
Gallagher MS '19
Barrington HS '23
DarthBuilder
Member
Member
Posts: 288
Joined: August 1st, 2017, 8:02 am
Division: Grad
State: IL
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Towers B/C

Post by DarthBuilder »

stevepilot wrote:Does anyone know if 1/32 x 1/32 wood would be strong enough for the chimney X's (provided a fairly tight interval of 8-10 X)? Also, is it necessary to have a ladder at the top of the chimney or is it only needed at the top and bottom of the base?
I’ve actually tried the 1/32 x 1/32

It is going to make the top weaker but it does work. But I wouldn’t use it. You can still get the same weights with 1/16
Deleted
User avatar
MadCow2357
Exalted Member
Exalted Member
Posts: 774
Joined: November 19th, 2017, 9:09 am
Division: C
State: RI
Has thanked: 211 times
Been thanked: 56 times
Contact:

Re: Towers B/C

Post by MadCow2357 »

When I do SFPD tests on my 1/8"*1/8"*12" pieces, I sort the pieces into 4 main groups based on buckling strength: weak(less than 200g), normal (200g to 240g), strong (240g to 300g), and exceptionally strong (300g+). I use the strongest pieces in the chimney, and the moderately strong pieces in all of the other essential load bearing columns. If I do not have enough of those, then I use the pieces with average buckling strength. Then, I use the weak pieces for the tension straps. But then I am always left with a pile of "weak" balsa. What would you guys do with that balsa?

Also, am I sorting my wood correctly (e.g. is less than 200g weak?)? I am referring to ~0.4g 12"*1/8"*1/8" pieces.
MadCow2357's Userpage
Gallagher MS '19
Barrington HS '23
DarthBuilder
Member
Member
Posts: 288
Joined: August 1st, 2017, 8:02 am
Division: Grad
State: IL
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Towers B/C

Post by DarthBuilder »

MadCow2357 wrote:When I do SFPD tests on my 1/8"*1/8"*12" pieces, I sort the pieces into 4 main groups based on buckling strength: weak(less than 200g), normal (200g to 240g), strong (240g to 300g), and exceptionally strong (300g+). I use the strongest pieces in the chimney, and the moderately strong pieces in all of the other essential load bearing columns. If I do not have enough of those, then I use the pieces with average buckling strength. Then, I use the weak pieces for the tension straps. But then I am always left with a pile of "weak" balsa. What would you guys do with that balsa?

Also, am I sorting my wood correctly (e.g. is less than 200g weak?)? I am referring to ~0.4g 12"*1/8"*1/8" pieces.
Anything near 300 give or take is pretty good
Deleted
User avatar
Cow481
Member
Member
Posts: 158
Joined: January 2nd, 2018, 6:18 pm
Division: B
State: PA
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Towers B/C

Post by Cow481 »

stevepilot wrote:Does anyone know if 1/32 x 1/32 wood would be strong enough for the chimney X's (provided a fairly tight interval of 8-10 X)? Also, is it necessary to have a ladder at the top of the chimney or is it only needed at the top and bottom of the base?
I would say that the wood dimensions don’t matter as much as the weight of the wood for bracings.
Medals
Invitationals: 9
Regionals: 5
States: 1
Nationals: 1

National Medals
2018: 5th in Towers
2019: Could have gotten top 3 in Boomilevers and Gliders if my team made it :cry:
stevepilot
Member
Member
Posts: 13
Joined: January 20th, 2018, 3:35 pm
Division: C
State: IA
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Towers B/C

Post by stevepilot »

Ok, thanks for the replies.
ST
2018 - Optics, Thermodynamics, Towers.

In memory of Len Joeris (Balsa Man)

2018 Towers - 4th
User avatar
cheese
Member
Member
Posts: 211
Joined: April 8th, 2017, 7:59 pm
Division: C
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Towers B/C

Post by cheese »

Cow481 wrote:
stevepilot wrote:Does anyone know if 1/32 x 1/32 wood would be strong enough for the chimney X's (provided a fairly tight interval of 8-10 X)? Also, is it necessary to have a ladder at the top of the chimney or is it only needed at the top and bottom of the base?
I would say that the wood dimensions don’t matter as much as the weight of the wood for bracings.
But there are certain relationships between the size and the strength that could make a difference.
2018 Nationals: 2nd Place Mystery Architecture || 6th Place Battery Buggy
Cheese's Userpage
dholdgreve
Coach
Coach
Posts: 573
Joined: February 6th, 2006, 2:20 pm
Division: B
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 7 times

Re: Towers B/C

Post by dholdgreve »

MadCow2357 wrote:When I do SFPD tests on my 1/8"*1/8"*12" pieces, I sort the pieces into 4 main groups based on buckling strength: weak(less than 200g), normal (200g to 240g), strong (240g to 300g), and exceptionally strong (300g+). I use the strongest pieces in the chimney, and the moderately strong pieces in all of the other essential load bearing columns. If I do not have enough of those, then I use the pieces with average buckling strength. Then, I use the weak pieces for the tension straps. But then I am always left with a pile of "weak" balsa. What would you guys do with that balsa?

Also, am I sorting my wood correctly (e.g. is less than 200g weak?)? I am referring to ~0.4g 12"*1/8"*1/8" pieces.
While I fully support the scientific approach you are taking, I'll throw a couple additional thoughts out there:
SFPD strength and stick weight are both very critical... I can hand you .9 to 1.0 gram 12" sticks in which every single stick will test off the charts in strength... And when you finish your 12 to 15 gram tower you won't be happy!
I'd suggest the you first stratify your sticks by weight (by tenths of a gram)... next, determine the weight of desired columns based on the overall tower weight. If you ultimately determine that .3 to .4 gram columns are needed, grab your pile of preweighed columns within that range and further stratify, using SFPD strength test. Next is where we differ... I believe the higher SFPD testing sticks should be turned into LOWER columns, not upper. The lower columns incur all of the loads the upper columns do, plus since they are at more of an angle will pick up addition shear... If you don't believe me, pick up a 10 pound weight in each hand. Hold one weight straight down by your side (the same angle as the upper column). Hold the other weight out from your body about 18"... approximately the same angle as the lower section of the tower... Hold both weights as long as you can... Which arm gives our first?

This premise is of course based on bracing design and assumes that your unsupported column lengths are similar in both the top and bottom sections. If you were to elect to go with half the number of tiers in the upper section than the lower section, then I believe the upper columns could need to be stronger than the lower columns.
Dan Holdgreve
Northmont Science Olympiad

Dedicated to the Memory of Len Joeris
"For the betterment of Science"
User avatar
Cow481
Member
Member
Posts: 158
Joined: January 2nd, 2018, 6:18 pm
Division: B
State: PA
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Towers B/C

Post by Cow481 »

I know that this is really late in the season but I was wondering whether the bonus was more efficient or the non bonus was more efficient.
Medals
Invitationals: 9
Regionals: 5
States: 1
Nationals: 1

National Medals
2018: 5th in Towers
2019: Could have gotten top 3 in Boomilevers and Gliders if my team made it :cry:
User avatar
MadCow2357
Exalted Member
Exalted Member
Posts: 774
Joined: November 19th, 2017, 9:09 am
Division: C
State: RI
Has thanked: 211 times
Been thanked: 56 times
Contact:

Re: Towers B/C

Post by MadCow2357 »

Thanks for the long and detailed response. You remind me so much of Balsa Man... may he rest in peace...

Anyways, I will keep what you said in mind. The arm holding the weight goes first.

I am thinking of switching to square base before nationals. How much would I have to spend to build the 2 acrylic panel jig, if I am laser cutting it at a local business?
MadCow2357's Userpage
Gallagher MS '19
Barrington HS '23
Locked

Return to “Towers B/C”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests