No show at nationals?
-
- Member
- Posts: 53
- Joined: August 3rd, 2013, 9:00 am
- Division: Grad
- State: CA
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: No show at nationals?
Going to Nats take a lot of funding and planning (logistics) as well as time and effort (for events), so any plans involving a standby team are going to be fairly unfavorable, either financially or emotionally, for said standby team. And this year, we didn't know about either no show until a day or so before, which is way too little time to find replacement teams.
Honestly, the most reasonable policy would be to just take a bid away for a year from any state that no-showed without some sort of emergency and/or prior warning. In this case, MS would lose their Div B bid for 2020, whereas VT would be fine since they had an emergency and communicated accordingly. There's too many schools that want to go to Nats for no shows to be a thing.
Honestly, the most reasonable policy would be to just take a bid away for a year from any state that no-showed without some sort of emergency and/or prior warning. In this case, MS would lose their Div B bid for 2020, whereas VT would be fine since they had an emergency and communicated accordingly. There's too many schools that want to go to Nats for no shows to be a thing.
Div D! I really like chem, oceanography, and nail polish--not in that order.
Troy HS, co2016.
Feel free to PM me about SciOly or college or whatever! I really enjoy making online friends.
Troy HS, co2016.
Feel free to PM me about SciOly or college or whatever! I really enjoy making online friends.
- Riptide
- Exalted Member
- Posts: 202
- Joined: December 4th, 2017, 7:09 pm
- Division: Grad
- State: TX
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 8 times
- Contact:
Re: No show at nationals?
Taking it away from a state seems like unnecessary punishment, but not allowing the specific school to attend would be more reasonable.primitive_polonium wrote:Going to Nats take a lot of funding and planning (logistics) as well as time and effort (for events), so any plans involving a standby team are going to be fairly unfavorable, either financially or emotionally, for said standby team. And this year, we didn't know about either no show until a day or so before, which is way too little time to find replacement teams.
Honestly, the most reasonable policy would be to just take a bid away for a year from any state that no-showed without some sort of emergency and/or prior warning. In this case, MS would lose their Div B bid for 2020, whereas VT would be fine since they had an emergency and communicated accordingly. There's too many schools that want to go to Nats for no shows to be a thing.
UC Berkeley
Seven Lakes High School '19
Seven Lakes High School '19
- EastStroudsburg13
- Admin Emeritus
- Posts: 3204
- Joined: January 17th, 2009, 7:32 am
- Division: Grad
- State: PA
- Pronouns: He/Him/His
- Has thanked: 49 times
- Been thanked: 204 times
- Contact:
Re: No show at nationals?
I dunno. It's harsh, but if there's no extenuating circumstances, there's no excuse for this sort of thing to happen. Maybe a state one-year freeze could occur for the second offense, while the first offense could just cause a freeze for the specific school.Riptide wrote:Taking it away from a state seems like unnecessary punishment, but not allowing the specific school to attend would be more reasonable.primitive_polonium wrote:Going to Nats take a lot of funding and planning (logistics) as well as time and effort (for events), so any plans involving a standby team are going to be fairly unfavorable, either financially or emotionally, for said standby team. And this year, we didn't know about either no show until a day or so before, which is way too little time to find replacement teams.
Honestly, the most reasonable policy would be to just take a bid away for a year from any state that no-showed without some sort of emergency and/or prior warning. In this case, MS would lose their Div B bid for 2020, whereas VT would be fine since they had an emergency and communicated accordingly. There's too many schools that want to go to Nats for no shows to be a thing.
East Stroudsburg South Class of 2012, Alumnus of JT Lambert, Drexel University Class of 2017
Helpful Links
Wiki
Wiki Pages that Need Work
FAQ and SciOly FAQ Wiki
Chat (See IRC Wiki for more info)
BBCode Wiki
So long, and thanks for all the Future Dictator titles!
Helpful Links
Wiki
Wiki Pages that Need Work
FAQ and SciOly FAQ Wiki
Chat (See IRC Wiki for more info)
BBCode Wiki
So long, and thanks for all the Future Dictator titles!
-
- Member
- Posts: 150
- Joined: March 17th, 2019, 9:12 am
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: No show at nationals?
But does anyone know if the MS B team had an emergency or not?
I agree with primitive_polonium that there's way too many teams who want to go to nats for a no-show to happen for no reason. The most reasonable punishment to me seems to be EastStroudsburg13's idea with freezing the school one year, and then freezing the state if it happens again.EastStroudsburg13 wrote:I dunno. It's harsh, but if there's no extenuating circumstances, there's no excuse for this sort of thing to happen. Maybe a state one-year freeze could occur for the second offense, while the first offense could just cause a freeze for the specific school.Riptide wrote:Taking it away from a state seems like unnecessary punishment, but not allowing the specific school to attend would be more reasonable.primitive_polonium wrote: Honestly, the most reasonable policy would be to just take a bid away for a year from any state that no-showed without some sort of emergency and/or prior warning. In this case, MS would lose their Div B bid for 2020, whereas VT would be fine since they had an emergency and communicated accordingly. There's too many schools that want to go to Nats for no shows to be a thing.
-
- Member
- Posts: 53
- Joined: August 3rd, 2013, 9:00 am
- Division: Grad
- State: CA
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Re: No show at nationals?
If they did, they didn't (haven't?) communicate to anyone about it...TheCrazyChemist wrote:But does anyone know if the MS B team had an emergency or not?
Maybe they did reach out to the tourney organizers when they could, but as of Saturday at Nats, no one knew where they were or what happened.
I've heard Maine's (I think it's Maine) Nats team was like their 3rd or 4th place team at states--there's clearly a lot of Nats interest out there. In hindsight, freezing the entire state on a first offense might be too much, but there should be some kind of consequence for no-showing without prior warning/emergency.
Edit: both divisions of Maine's Nats teams placed 2nd at states.
Last edited by primitivepolonium on July 2nd, 2019, 12:33 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Div D! I really like chem, oceanography, and nail polish--not in that order.
Troy HS, co2016.
Feel free to PM me about SciOly or college or whatever! I really enjoy making online friends.
Troy HS, co2016.
Feel free to PM me about SciOly or college or whatever! I really enjoy making online friends.
- EastStroudsburg13
- Admin Emeritus
- Posts: 3204
- Joined: January 17th, 2009, 7:32 am
- Division: Grad
- State: PA
- Pronouns: He/Him/His
- Has thanked: 49 times
- Been thanked: 204 times
- Contact:
Re: No show at nationals?
Both of Maine's teams this year placed 2nd at their state tournament.primitive_polonium wrote:If they did, they didn't (haven't?) communicate to anyone about it...TheCrazyChemist wrote:But does anyone know if the MS B team had an emergency or not?
Maybe they did reach out to the tourney organizers when they could, but as of Saturday at Nats, no one knew where they were or what happened.
I've heard Maine's (I think it's Maine) Nats team was like their 3rd or 4th place team at states--there's clearly a lot of Nats interest out there. In hindsight, freezing the entire state on a first offense might be too much, but there should be some kind of consequence for no-showing without prior warning/emergency.
East Stroudsburg South Class of 2012, Alumnus of JT Lambert, Drexel University Class of 2017
Helpful Links
Wiki
Wiki Pages that Need Work
FAQ and SciOly FAQ Wiki
Chat (See IRC Wiki for more info)
BBCode Wiki
So long, and thanks for all the Future Dictator titles!
Helpful Links
Wiki
Wiki Pages that Need Work
FAQ and SciOly FAQ Wiki
Chat (See IRC Wiki for more info)
BBCode Wiki
So long, and thanks for all the Future Dictator titles!
-
- Member
- Posts: 233
- Joined: January 9th, 2015, 6:28 pm
- Division: B
- State: NY
- Has thanked: 124 times
- Been thanked: 13 times
- Contact:
Re: No show at nationals?
That sounds like a great idea to me (but I might be just a tad biased). Sincerely, NY's 3rd Place teamsturmde wrote:I've thought for many years... that having a "standby" team from the host state could be possible.
.
For example, since the Cornell tournament was in New York, the third place team from New York could have been there as a 'demonstration' team similar to the Japanese team. In the event a team had a last minute cancellation, a team that wouldn't have incurred a major distance travel would be able to fill in.
.
It would seem to be a nice inducement to a state to be very involved in hosting, if their second (or third for larger states) were in such a position. For 2020, this would suggest that North Carolina have its third team on standby...
- builderguy135
- Exalted Member
- Posts: 736
- Joined: September 8th, 2018, 12:24 pm
- Division: C
- State: NJ
- Pronouns: He/Him/His
- Has thanked: 191 times
- Been thanked: 143 times
- Contact:
Re: No show at nationals?
I think this is actually a pretty good idea, minus freezing the state on the second year. It just seems kinda harsh for everyone else in the state (second or 3rd place teams).EastStroudsburg13 wrote:I dunno. It's harsh, but if there's no extenuating circumstances, there's no excuse for this sort of thing to happen. Maybe a state one-year freeze could occur for the second offense, while the first offense could just cause a freeze for the specific school.Riptide wrote:Taking it away from a state seems like unnecessary punishment, but not allowing the specific school to attend would be more reasonable.primitive_polonium wrote:Going to Nats take a lot of funding and planning (logistics) as well as time and effort (for events), so any plans involving a standby team are going to be fairly unfavorable, either financially or emotionally, for said standby team. And this year, we didn't know about either no show until a day or so before, which is way too little time to find replacement teams.
Honestly, the most reasonable policy would be to just take a bid away for a year from any state that no-showed without some sort of emergency and/or prior warning. In this case, MS would lose their Div B bid for 2020, whereas VT would be fine since they had an emergency and communicated accordingly. There's too many schools that want to go to Nats for no shows to be a thing.
- EastStroudsburg13
- Admin Emeritus
- Posts: 3204
- Joined: January 17th, 2009, 7:32 am
- Division: Grad
- State: PA
- Pronouns: He/Him/His
- Has thanked: 49 times
- Been thanked: 204 times
- Contact:
Re: No show at nationals?
That's part of the idea. If it happens one year, and the state takes no precautions to make any changes in a subsequent year, there should be a stiffer punishment.builderguy135 wrote:I think this is actually a pretty good idea, minus freezing the state on the second year. It just seems kinda harsh for everyone else in the state (second or 3rd place teams).EastStroudsburg13 wrote:I dunno. It's harsh, but if there's no extenuating circumstances, there's no excuse for this sort of thing to happen. Maybe a state one-year freeze could occur for the second offense, while the first offense could just cause a freeze for the specific school.Riptide wrote: Taking it away from a state seems like unnecessary punishment, but not allowing the specific school to attend would be more reasonable.
East Stroudsburg South Class of 2012, Alumnus of JT Lambert, Drexel University Class of 2017
Helpful Links
Wiki
Wiki Pages that Need Work
FAQ and SciOly FAQ Wiki
Chat (See IRC Wiki for more info)
BBCode Wiki
So long, and thanks for all the Future Dictator titles!
Helpful Links
Wiki
Wiki Pages that Need Work
FAQ and SciOly FAQ Wiki
Chat (See IRC Wiki for more info)
BBCode Wiki
So long, and thanks for all the Future Dictator titles!
- builderguy135
- Exalted Member
- Posts: 736
- Joined: September 8th, 2018, 12:24 pm
- Division: C
- State: NJ
- Pronouns: He/Him/His
- Has thanked: 191 times
- Been thanked: 143 times
- Contact:
Re: No show at nationals?
How would the state take precautions to make sure a team attends? Would they have the right to elect a different team or give out stricter punishments to those who no show?EastStroudsburg13 wrote:That's part of the idea. If it happens one year, and the state takes no precautions to make any changes in a subsequent year, there should be a stiffer punishment.builderguy135 wrote:I think this is actually a pretty good idea, minus freezing the state on the second year. It just seems kinda harsh for everyone else in the state (second or 3rd place teams).EastStroudsburg13 wrote: I dunno. It's harsh, but if there's no extenuating circumstances, there's no excuse for this sort of thing to happen. Maybe a state one-year freeze could occur for the second offense, while the first offense could just cause a freeze for the specific school.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests