Science Olympiad is really unfair. (Small rant)

Shoot the breeze with other Olympians.
Post Reply
SciOlyEnthusiast
Member
Member
Posts: 0
Joined: March 21st, 2023, 6:37 pm
Division: B
State: MN
Pronouns: He/Him/His
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Science Olympiad is really unfair. (Small rant)

Post by SciOlyEnthusiast »

I’m in middle school in MN and I’m not part of a team but my friends are and they have had a really bad experience with science Olympiad that makes me kind of angry as well.

For months they stayed multiple hours after school twice a week, then every day for hours for the last 2 weeks leading up to the state competition (they won regionals).

Now my middle school is kind of bad. It funds almost no clubs even though we have some of the smartest kids in the state (which is really unfair). During this year’s state competition they did extremely well, one of my friends scoring gold medals in all of his events and my other friends has a ton of gold, silver, and bronze medals. I don’t think anyone got below fourth in their respective events.

However, as I states earlier, we got NO access to materials and study resources because our school is…. bad. Some of my friends had to use their OWN (not their parents’) money to buy 1 book for one of their events.

In the state competition, they placed 2nd, 2 POINTS BEHIND THE WINNING SCHOOL. do you even realize how close that it!?!?! This gets much worse when you learn the winning middle school has 4 teams with 12 members each while my school’s team has 1 team with ~8 members. In addition, it’s fully funded by the school and they have endless amount of resources and things like that.

IT GETS EVEN WORSE. According to the Minnesota SciOly website, 1. That school has won state every year since they started SciOly and 2. Registering an extra team costs 100$ per team. That means THE MONEY IT TAKES TO BUY 3 EXTRA TEAMS IS MORE THAN 3X AS MUCH MONEY AS OUR SCHOOL NEEDED TO BUY ENOUGH RESOURCES TO DEFINITELY WIN. not even COUNTING the materials that other school bought for their students.

And, on top of all of that, my friends had to literally fund their own pizza party (mandatory) and give the trophy to the school without question. There is also NO ADVERTISEMENT for Science Olympiad other than a one time, short announcement over morning announcements.

I’m not blaming Science Olympiad. I blame my school. But I wished that Science Olympiad would just think of all of the amazing students being hindered by their dumb schools and make it somewhat fair??? I think it’s so unfair we got 2nd just because we didn’t have enough resources because our school is worse. I wish it actually provided the materials and books that we need to study and learn. We could’ve easily won with just the cost it takes for registering ONE extra team to Science Olympiad.

Please just consider this.

Thank you for reading.
ypang9804
Member
Member
Posts: 2
Joined: February 20th, 2023, 11:27 am
Division: B
State: CA
Pronouns: He/Him/His
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Science Olympiad is really unfair. (Small rant)

Post by ypang9804 »

Hi there! While I have only done Scioly for a year, I have done other competitions, and here are my opinions.
I am not going to deny your efforts and your team's efforts. Be proud of that, and know you accomplished something on your own initiative without the help of your school. However, I do have some issues with what you said.
Firstly, Scioly is a competition, some people win, some people lose. A cutoff has to be drawn between who can move on and who can't. It might be a close race, but it might not. But at the end of the day, some really good teams don't make it. It is an unfortunate and brutal reality.
Secondly, Scioly is only an organization that provides tests and organizes events, they are not supposed to provide the resources to help you study. It is up to the competitors, in this case, students, to take the initiative and work for it. While the school can provide resources, they may not always be enough or helpful.
Third, Scioly Organization has limited money, they can't provide quality resources on large scale. A textbook can easily cost 100 dollars, multiply that by thousands, if not tens of thousands of competitors. This can get very, very, expensive. Writers of resources have their own time, they might not be able to afford to provide quality materials without pay.
Fourth, Scioly, the organization, can't do much to support struggling teams like yours. From a realistic standpoint, they could provide grants to schools with low funding, but I really do not see anything else practical. They can't say "Oh team X gets to go to nats, even though they had higher points than Team Y, simply because they had a horrible school/coach/etc."
Fifth, Scioly is expensive and needs experience. 100 dollars likely won't cut it. Engineering events can easily cost a few hundred dollars total due to the needed parts and tools. Travel costs, books, and everything else, all take up money. Poor funding can make or break things, but again, the Scioly organization can't do much besides provide some grants. Furthermore, experience matters. A coach with good experience can and will make or break a team's win. They know how the rules work, where to bend them, and how to maximize a team's chance of winning.
Again, this isn't to say Scioly is perfect. Personally, I think many of the engineering events can be pay to win (everyone shows up with the same car/bridge). There always is that one school that is so much better equipped and organized in every state, and it isn't easy to catch up. Schools do matter, a lot, but they are only part of the equation. Students, therefore the team, make up the rest. Both sides need to carry their weight, but at the end of the day, the team will always have to give in more if the school or coach can't or won't.
User avatar
onshape
Member
Member
Posts: 107
Joined: January 28th, 2023, 11:42 am
Division: C
State: VA
Pronouns: Ask My Pronouns
Has thanked: 20 times
Been thanked: 24 times
Contact:

Re: Science Olympiad is really unfair. (Small rant)

Post by onshape »

It's not about where you end up, it's about your experiences and what you learned. Making it to 2nd in states is something to be proud of, some teams like ours didn't even make it to states. I do agree that some build events can be based off of the resources that you have, but at the same time, studying an hour a day for Chem Lab got me 22nd at regionals. Sometimes that's just how it works.
"I know two kinds of audiences only - one coughing, and one not coughing." -Artur Schnabel
"In the beginning was rhythm." -Hans von Bulow
"The art of music entombed a rich possession, but even far fairer hopes." -Franz Grillparzer
knightmoves
Member
Member
Posts: 629
Joined: April 26th, 2018, 6:40 pm
Has thanked: 4 times
Been thanked: 108 times

Re: Science Olympiad is really unfair. (Small rant)

Post by knightmoves »

SciOlyEnthusiast wrote: March 21st, 2023, 6:52 pm I’m in middle school in MN and I’m not part of a team but my friends are and they have had a really bad experience with science Olympiad that makes me kind of angry as well.

In the state competition, they placed 2nd, 2 POINTS BEHIND THE WINNING SCHOOL. do you even realize how close that it!?!?! This gets much worse when you learn the winning middle school has 4 teams with 12 members each while my school’s team has 1 team with ~8 members. In addition, it’s fully funded by the school and they have endless amount of resources and things like that.
I'm confused. If your team placed second in Minnesota, then your team is Black Hawk Middle School, and finished 23 points behind Chippewa. Looks like your team did well, particularly for a team with only 8 members, which means you must have had a number of events with a teammate competing solo. But then I'd have to ask why your team's website clearly features a picture of 13 people posing on a stage with medals and trophies.
User avatar
pumptato-cat
Exalted Member
Exalted Member
Posts: 340
Joined: June 15th, 2022, 11:04 am
Division: C
Pronouns: She/Her/Hers
Has thanked: 103 times
Been thanked: 77 times
Contact:

Re: Science Olympiad is really unfair. (Small rant)

Post by pumptato-cat »

I agree with everything everyone above has said.
As someone who comes from a team that has no school support and funds everything ourselves, it's not easy.
That school has won state every year since they started SciOly and 2. Registering an extra team costs 100$ per team. That means THE MONEY IT TAKES TO BUY 3 EXTRA TEAMS IS MORE THAN 3X AS MUCH MONEY AS OUR SCHOOL NEEDED TO BUY ENOUGH RESOURCES TO DEFINITELY WIN. not even COUNTING the materials that other school bought for their students.
I'd like to state a couple of things here. Your team is not going to win by spending $100. If knightmoves is correct, more money will likely not make up for the 23 points between 1st and 2nd. Also, spending more money to buy resources won't cause you to "definitely win". Builds are about spending money and putting significant time and effort into each and every event. If Chippewa put more funds into build events, I wouldn't call the results unfair.
Note: I am in no way trying to discredit your team's accomplishments.
SciOlyEnthusiast wrote: March 21st, 2023, 6:52 pm I’m not blaming Science Olympiad. I blame my school. But I wished that Science Olympiad would just think of all of the amazing students being hindered by their dumb schools and make it somewhat fair??? I think it’s so unfair we got 2nd just because we didn’t have enough resources because our school is worse. I wish it actually provided the materials and books that we need to study and learn. We could’ve easily won with just the cost it takes for registering ONE extra team to Science Olympiad.
1. I do not think Science Olympiad is unfair. Those who have more money and resources win. Those who spend more time win. It's just how things are.
2. You can provide materials and books yourself. I found textbooks on Ebay for $20. They were quite helpful, but you can also get along just fine by using the internet. There are countless resources out there on the internet, and you can succeed in every event by using them. Also, again, $100 isn't going to make you "easily [win]". To a certain extent, some SciOly events are pay-to-win. But it's also about how you can utilize the resources you already have and work around obstacles like this. If you want to win, you find a way. No matter how crappy your situation is, or how low your team is on funds, you find a way. If that means that I have to save up my money and spend it all on SciOly, sure--if that's what it takes to win, and if I want to win, I'll do it.

Like onshape said, it's about what you learn along the way and what you gain, not where you end up. You mentioned "amazing students being hindered by their dumb schools". I wouldn't say your school is dumb... you had the opportunity to attend SciOly and put together a team.

I get that you're angry and frustrated, but this is just how SciOly works. You want something, you work for it. If you're low on funds, you get some. If you have nowhere to practice, you find a place. If you want recognition, you promote your team. There is always a solution--you just have to find it.
Good luck next season! Don't be discouraged--and hey, did your team learn something? Or have fun at practices/tourneys? If so, that's great. The point isn't to win tournaments. It's to have fun and learn stuff. :)
anything'll fly if you throw it hard enough
User avatar
Jehosaphat
Member
Member
Posts: 55
Joined: November 8th, 2018, 3:50 pm
Division: Grad
State: MI
Pronouns: He/Him/His
Has thanked: 38 times
Been thanked: 20 times
Contact:

Re: Science Olympiad is really unfair. (Small rant)

Post by Jehosaphat »

I would say your story almost proves how fair Scioly is. The fact you took second at states with as little resources as you did is awesome. There are activities where money directly translates to performance, and Scioly is definitely on the better end of that spectrum.

I competed in Scioly for the full seven years, and slight confession, I never used a text book. All of my research came from the internet, and I competed at a high level with only that level of information. Is that saying that text books don't help? No, but today there is more information available for free than ever before, and taking advantage of that will take you much further than a textbook ever will.

Money is important, and my school is plenty underfunded as well. We operated on $600 a year, which is not even in the same ballpark as some top teams. But we still showed up, had fun, and Scioly is where I made some of my best memories. It's not easy to be the best, and maybe you will have to put in a more work than the other kids will. But that's just life.
Waiting for the return of Ecology all by myself
HHS '22
Hope '26
Post Reply

Return to “General Chat”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests